Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Tools like this are cutting off the branch they are sitting on. If you block all the ads on an ad-supported website, how will it survive?


The branch that uBlock sits on is not ad revenue. It's people's annoyance at constantly being subjected to intrusive user tracking, especially for sites that they have little choice to not use. Think social networks and banks. Sure you can refuse to use them entirely on principle, but it's not a practical approach if you want to actually have a life.

On top of that, much of the tracking that does go on is actually blatantly illegal in how it's done, at least in the EU. It's just too small-time to enforce at scale. Doesn't mean I have to take this as a given.


I agree that tracking and ads are different. But uBlock does include ad-blocking functionality. The discussion here suggests that most people use it for that.


> If you block all the ads on an ad-supported website, how will it survive?

If the only thing that website provides of value is a billboard, it doesn't deserve to.

I'm perfectly happy paying for high-quality ad-free services.


So why do you use any websites that have ads/tracking? Surely you could avoid them and stick to your high quality paid options?

It’s annoying how self-righteous HN is about Ads.


> So why do you use any websites that have ads/tracking?

Because it's extremely easy to disable the ads.

> Surely you could avoid them and stick to your high quality paid options?

I don't want to avoid the websites, I want to avoid the ads. If that at some point necessitates avoiding the website then sure, but fortunately it doesn't at the moment.


If uBlock makes itself redundant by killing all ad-supported websites for good, that sounds like a fantastic outcome. In this case, I will personally fund the creator's retirement.


Adapt? That's what most industries that face change do.

How did sites survive before the ad infestation business model?


Could you be more specific, and say what strategies an ad-supported site might use to provide the same content?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: