Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Aren't decreasing infant and child mortality rates making it falsely appear so to some extent?


Especially when combined with really good acute medical care and reductions in infections. Of course, how much of the infection reduction is a result of washing with soap is an open question.


Ignaz Semmelweis came up with his germ theory after observing a strong correlation of infections with whether people performing certain tasks in hospitals washed their hands or not.


Yes, this is true. Life expectancy of adults has gone up, but only a bit; the heavy increase in average age is due to a heavy drop off of birth/child mortality.

The average media reporting and understanding of statistics makes it seem as if a 50 year old person in medieval times was a rare occurrence, which it was not.

(at least I think this is what you were saying?)


Your question is a bit confusing...

If a baby/child doesn't die, then the only logical conclusion is that it is (and by extension "us" are) living longer...which validates his statement.


Yeah, but decreasing only this infant mortality does not make the individuals live longer. It's just that we have been efficient at removing one cause of death at one end of the spectrum, but not at the other end so much. So as long as you are born and alive, your life expectancy is not really increasing versus people who were alive 50 years ago, after the discovery of penicillin let's say.


Infant and child mortality is down _and_ we're living longer.


> _and_ we're living longer.

This is mainly due to the improvement of hospital facilities and the end of life treatments. we are not living longer better - the older you get the more cripple you are likely to survive. What really matters in life expectancy is the ability to live longer in good health.


The improvement of hospital facilities owe a great deal to humanity's ability to destroy germs at will when it is important to do so, e.g. during/after surgery.

http://jfh.sagepub.com/content/14/3/195.abstract

Hospitals were death traps 200 years ago.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: